Site Loader

Summer Of My German Soldier Essay, Research Paper

The novel, Summer of My German Soldier, written by Bette Greene is about a immature Jewish miss, Patty, who befriends a Nazi soldier. She confides in him because of the deficiency of parental love in her life. The Nazi soldier shows Patty that she is a individual of value and is of import in the universe. This is something that her parents have ne’er told her. Michael Tuchner, manager of the cinematic version of, Summer of My German Soldier, does a just occupation of portraying the action in the novel, nevertheless some cardinal scenes are non shown therefore taking away of import facts that the spectator would see.

We Will Write a Custom Essay Specifically
For You For Only $13.90/page!


order now

There are many scenes in the film that are non in the book. There are a few cardinal add-ons, one of which is, Anton inquiring Patty for accoutrements. The accoutrements are a toothbrush, toothpaste, razor, comb, etc. When he is inquiring for these things he seems truly demanding. In the book he does non look to be this manner. Another add-on is, towards the terminal of the film, Patty & # 8217 ; s male parent comes into her room and tells her that she is a bad individual and is dead to him. He besides tells her that she has ever hated him, and in a manner this compares to the scene in the book where he goes into the garage and yells & # 8220 ; cipher loves me, cipher loves me! & # 8221 ; . The scene in which Ruth walks through the town with Patty is another cardinal add-on. It shows that she is confident in herself and that she is non afraid of the bias of the white people. This scene closely compares to the scene in the book where Ruth orders the white guards in the juvenile detainment centre to bring Patty & # 8217 ; s Christmas bag.

There are many scenes in the book that do non take topographic point in the film. The most evident omission is of the scenes covering with the grandparents. In the film Patty & # 8217 ; s grandparents are ne’er mentioned ; in the book they play a major function in her life. In the beginning of the book, before Patty meets Anton, her grandparents are all she has. Unlike her parents, they treat her like a individual. Besides at the terminal of the book they keep her before she has to travel to the juvenile detainment centre. The film does non demo any of that. Another omission that occurs is Patty & # 8217 ; s penalty for lodging the Nazi. In the book she is sent to the juvenile detainment centre as a penalty. In the film all that is said is that she will be acquiring a attorney to assist battle for her. Many of the interactions between Patty and her male parent are non shown in the film. In the book Mr. Bergen beats Patty legion times ; in the film Mr. Bergen merely beats her one time. Alternatively of crushing her, he merely yells violently at her. This is likely done to maintain the evaluation of the film minimal. Besides, when Patty goes out to see Anton during the dark, in the book

her male parent catches her in the kitchen ; in the film she sneaks out via the window and is non caught.

A few scenes had the same result between the film and book, but the manner in which they were done is different. One major illustration of this is the scenes that involve Anton & # 8217 ; s go forthing. In the book, it is at dark and it is long and dramatic. They besides kiss right before he runs into the dark. In the film, it is during the twenty-four hours and really abrupt. The FBI comes to the Bergen & # 8217 ; s house to seek for the Nazi. Anton is forced to go forth because he does non desire to be found. They do non snog in the film, but Anton does give Patty a buss on the brow before he leaves. Another illustration of the alterations which take topographic point are the book & # 8217 ; s and film & # 8217 ; s version of the rock throwing episode. In the book Patty goes out to look for the people whose window she broke to pay them back with Ruth & # 8217 ; s money. She gets to her male parent & # 8217 ; s shop and sees that the auto is at that place. Her dad gets to her before she can acquire to them and he beats her without even listening to what she has to state. In the film Patty gets the money from Ruth and starts to go forth. She does non even acquire out of the house before her pa walks in and starts to shout at her. She tries to state him that she is traveling to pay them for the window but he merely covers her oral cavity and cries.

During the film many things take topographic point in different times for which they took topographic point in the book. In the film Anton escapes during the first portion ; in the book Anton doesn & # 8217 ; t get away until more than midway through. Besides in the book, the sermonizers & # 8217 ; married woman complains to Ms. Bergen about how Ruth got all of the beefburger before she could. She tells Ms. Bergen to fire Ruth, but Ms. Bergen refuses to. This scene takes topographic point in the first twosome of scenes of the book. In the film that episode does non go on until about the terminal of the film. This may be like this to announce what is to go on to Ruth in the hereafter.

Cinematic techniques were used sagely in the film. The costuming is really good. Freddy could decidedly be seen as a hapless male child, Ruth decidedly looked like a house worker, Sharon had the image of a small priggish miss, and Patty was decidedly given the image a miss who is treated like rubbish by her parents. The scene in the film does non at all differ from the book. The struggle in the film is besides the same as the books.

In decision, the film and the book have the same purposes merely some scenes are either added, detracted, changed, or rearranged. I would urge this film to the survey of the novel merely the reader needs to maintain in head that there are differences between the two things. They present the same thought but some things are merely done otherwise.

33d

Post Author: admin

x

Hi!
I'm Jimmy!

Would you like to get a custom essay? How about receiving a customized one?

Check it out